Welcome to A Matter of Crust! We’re a cottage bakery specializing in scratch-made pastries and treats inspired by songs

Shop All

Sweet Dreams (are made of this)

Sweet Dreams (are made of this)

This Must Be the Place

Mushaboom Hand Pie (Vg) Mushaboom Hand Pie (Vg) Mushaboom Hand Pie (Vg) Mushaboom Hand Pie (Vg) Mushaboom Hand Pie (Vg)
Mushaboom Hand Pie (Vg)
from $5.00

New savory hand pie just dropped: Mushroom, leek, apple, and sage. In our flaky classic pie crust, brushed with garlic, and topped with cracked pepper, kosher salt, and sage leaf before baking to perfection!

Contains: Soy and Wheat

Vegan Friendly

All products are made in a kitchen that uses major food allergens: eggs, milk, wheat, soy, peanuts, tree nuts, sesame

I Put a Spell Pec-On You I Put a Spell Pec-On You I Put a Spell Pec-On You I Put a Spell Pec-On You
I Put a Spell Pec-On You
from $4.00

Fall is here, time to enjoy one of our favs. These addicting bars WILL put a spell on you if you’re not careful! Maple pecan pie filling atop brown butter shortbread crust, baked to perfection and sprinkled with sea salt for that perfect bite!

Contains: Eggs, Nuts, Milk, Wheat

The Great Pumpkin Hand Pie (GF) The Great Pumpkin Hand Pie (GF) The Great Pumpkin Hand Pie (GF) The Great Pumpkin Hand Pie (GF) The Great Pumpkin Hand Pie (GF)
The Great Pumpkin Hand Pie (GF)
from $5.00

Happy pumpkin season! This year we’ve made a delicious pumpkin butter from scratch and baked it into our crumbly gluten-free-friendly pie crust! Drizzled with pumpkin spice icing, these hand pies are perfect for any pumpkin lover!

Pie pumpkins sourced from Stahlman’s at Bear Creek in New Braunfels!

Contains: Milk

Comes in our Gluten Free Crust unless otherwise requested

All products are made in a kitchen that uses major food allergens: eggs, milk, wheat, soy, peanuts, tree nuts, sesame

Follow us on social

Close-up of freshly baked chocolate chip cookies on a cooling rack.
Pieces of square pastry dough with dollops of pie filling on top, arranged on a flour-dusted surface.
Two clear plastic bags with baked goods inside, one containing a brown rectangular pastry with icing and the other a rectangular pastry with pink icing, held up against a background of a pink and purple sunset sky and outdoor light post.
Multiple homemade cookies with chocolate chips, individually wrapped in plastic, placed on a speckled countertop.
Instagram

Contact Us

Questions about ordering? Not finding what you’re looking for? Reach out to us and we’ll get back to you as soon as we can!